Ķvlog

School & District Management

Rural States Concerned About Federal Law

By Alan Richard — October 22, 2003 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

Governors of two largely rural states have written to Secretary of Education Rod Paige seeking his support for changes in the No Child Left Behind Act and its regulations, with a goal of helping small and remote schools meet the mandates of the law.

See Also...

Read the accompanying text, “Rural Concerns.”

Gov. Judy Martz of Montana, a Republican, and Gov. Bill Richardson of New Mexico, a Democrat, wrote in a joint letter dated Oct. 6 that their states need more flexibility under the law because many of their schools have tiny enrollments and special challenges.

“There’s parts of it that just can’t happen,” Kris Goss, the education adviser to Gov. Martz, said of the federal education law and its impact on rural states.

He noted, for example, the requirement that every state and school district provide a “highly qualified” teacher in every core academic classroom, meaning that teachers must hold degrees in the subjects they teach or pass exams on their subject-area knowledge.

Mr. Goss said that a majority of schools in Montana cannot meet that requirement, because teachers in smaller schools almost always teach multiple courses, and sometimes multiple grades. Failing those schools simply because of their size, or forcing schools to hire extra employees, isn’t realistic and wouldn’t necessarily improve the quality of the schools, he said.

“Without collective determination to address these problems from both the state and federal levels, Montana, New Mexico, and many other rural states will continue to experience difficulty in these crucial stages of implementation,” the two governors wrote in their letter to Mr. Paige, which they drafted after discussing it at a meeting of the Western Governors Association in September.

Fresh Criticism

The letter and other recent calls for changes in the No Child Left Behind law show that criticism over certain parts of the Bush administration’s signature education program is growing louder from some quarters across the country.

Gov. James E. McGreevey of New Jersey, a Democrat, complained in an Oct. 10 letter to Secretary Paige that many of his state’s schools had failed to meet strict test-score goals under the law because only a few students with disabilities or pupils learning to speak English didn’t meet academic standards. He wrote that many of the schools had been “falsely characterized” as failing, and he called for changes in the rules around “adequate yearly progress” on test scores and for more federal education funding.

Meanwhile, a group calling itself the Citizens for Effective Schools announced in New York City last week that more than 100 Ķvlog and public officials had signed a letter calling for changes in the law. The group includes former Gov. Frank Keating of Oklahoma, a Republican, although he does not go along with the group’s criticisms of the law.

Gov. Martz of Montana and Gov. Richardson of New Mexico made a number of specific requests in their letter, including some changes that would require Congress to amend the law.

For example, they call on the law to be changed to provide for a waiver on teacher-quality requirements that would allow states that met national averages on the National Assessment of Educational Progress to set their own standards.

The governors’ letter also calls for:

  • More federal money for state education departments to help low-performing schools, or a more flexible timeline for schools to make adequate yearly progress on test scores if extra money isn’t available.
  • A one-year exemption from test-score requirements and more help from the federal government in determining better ways to measure student progress in small schools.
  • The federal government to contract for help with data analysis and management in smaller states.
  • Delays in corrective action against rural schools, giving them more time to meet test-score goals.

Dan Langan, a Department of Education spokesman, said last week that the agency had not yet responded to the governors’ letter, but planned to do so.

Mr. Paige understands the concerns of rural states and schools about the law, but he believes the department is offering tremendous help and doesn’t see the need for changes in the law, Mr. Langan said.

“While there are many who think the law should be opened for a variety of reasons, the secretary and the department disagree,” Mr. Langan said. “We need to give the law a chance to work.”

The Education Department has an internal task force on rural schools looking at issues related to the law, and it recently held an online forum to show how technology can help schools follow the law, he said. Mr. Langan also noted that the department has sent “teacher-assistance corps” members and others to advise state officials.

As for the governors’ request for extra federal money, Mr. Langan added: “There already is extra money available, and a lot of it.”

Mr. Goss said that Gov. Martz is pushing for more federal aid to education, but so far hasn’t taken her call for changes in the No Child Left Behind law to Capitol Hill.

Events

Classroom Technology Live Online Discussion A Seat at the Table: The Rewiring of Childhood With Jonathan Haidt
Jonathan Haidt, Catherine Price, and Adam Swinyard join Peter DeWitt on how to get students off devices and back to the basics of childhood.
Professional Development K-12 Essentials Forum Getting Professional Development to Stick
Join this free virtual event to explore best practices, funding, format, and timing for teacher and principal PD.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
College & Workforce Readiness Webinar
The Road to Opportunity: Making CTE Accessible for All
The most valuable CTE happens off campus. For too many students, transportation is the barrier that keeps opportunity out of reach.
Content provided by HopSkipDrive

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

School & District Management Closing a School? Don't Expect to Save Money, a New Study Warns
The hope is that closing schools can reduce fixed costs. A new study looks into whether that happens.
5 min read
This is an aerial shot of a large public high school complex shot on a Sunday with nobody around. This image features multiple buildings, a running track, football fields, baseball diamonds, tennis courts parking lots and a residential neighborhood surrounding the image. Shot from the open window of a small plane.
Illustration by Education Week + Getty
School & District Management Quiz Quiz Yourself: How Much Do You Know About Events and PD for K-12 Educators?
From peer-led sessions to AI training, see how well you understand today’s K-12 professional development priorities.
School & District Management School Board Conflict Surged During the Pandemic. Has It Gone Away?
New research reveals how school boards navigated heightened levels of conflict in recent years.
5 min read
Seminole County, Fla., deputies remove parent Chris Mink of Apopka from an emergency meeting of the Seminole County School Board in Sanford, Fla., Thursday, Sept. 2, 2021. Mink, the parent of a Bear Lake Elementary School student, opposes a call for mask mandates for Seminole schools and was escorted out for shouting during the standing-room only meeting.
Seminole County, Fla., deputies remove parent Chris Mink of Apopka from an emergency meeting of the county school board in Sanford, Fla., Sept. 2, 2021, after he opposed a call for mask mandates and shouted. A new report gives a national picture of how school board conflict, including between boards and their communities, rose during the pandemic.
Joe Burbank/Orlando Sentinel via AP
School & District Management Opinion The 3 Predicable Struggles That Thwart Education Leadership Teams
Even highly capable leadership teams can struggle to translate their strengths into school impact.
4 min read
Screenshot 2026 06 08 at 7.13.09 AM
Canva