Ķvlog

Opinion
Mathematics Opinion

How We Can Finally End the ‘Math Wars’

Children lose out on learning when teachers don’t have clear direction
By Pedro A. Noguera & Morgan Polikoff — August 22, 2022 | Corrected: August 24, 2022 5 min read
Tug of war illustration with math equations.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

Corrected: A previous version of this essay included a widely quoted but outdated statistic for the proportion of Americans with math anxiety.

How should we teach children math?

Given that over 50 percent of Americans report that they fear and hate math and a large proportion say they experience math anxiety, this is not a trivial question. Math is the language of the 21st century, and who learns and uses math has major implications for who will have access to good jobs and other opportunities.

In many parts of the country, nonetheless, Ķvlog and policymakers are embroiled in debates over how to teach math. In Florida, the state’s governor has decided to make war against what he calls “woke math.” In California, the debate over the proposed is at the center of an all-out math war. While much of the public is oblivious to the conflagration there, it appears likely that millions of California’s children will lose out in the conflict.

The high-level outlines of the math curriculum wars have hardly changed over the years. On the one hand are proponents who advocate a “traditional” approach to take us “back to basics.” This approach emphasizes mostly procedural fluency in working math problems, traditional sequencing of courses, and teacher-directed instructional approaches. On the other side are the advocates who call for a more “reform-oriented” version of math. They argue that what is needed is greater relevance and application of mathematics to students’ lives, more mathematical thinking and problem solving, and a focus on more “modern” content like statistics and data science.

Although neither of us are math Ķvlog, we have followed the policy debates closely and are familiar with the issues involved. Both sides make valid points—but the combatants miss the larger point: While they fight over their broad visions for math instruction, Ķvlog are left with the impossible task of figuring out on their own what to do in the classroom right now as schools reopen. As is too often the case, kids are the most likely to lose out.

Presently, millions of students across the nation are far behind where they need to be in mathematics, and the pandemic has only made this worse. In California, even before the pandemic, just 40 percent of students were meeting state standards in mathematics. Even fewer, just 29 percent, were meeting national standards for proficiency on the National Assessment of Educational Progress. Recent reports make clear that student performance declined substantially during the pandemic—as much as a in the percent of children scoring at grade level in mathematics.

There are several reasons to be especially concerned about mathematics. First, while recent evidence suggests some of the reading losses during the pandemic have started to be addressed, math declines actually got in the 2021-22 school year. Second, by all accounts these declines are larger in schools serving more disadvantaged kids—students of color and students from low-income families. And third, these declines are considerably larger in schools that were closed for longer.

The good news is that schools have substantial supplemental funding from federal and state governments to address these glaring needs. The bad news is that schools are receiving little guidance on how to use those funds to address the needs of their students.
State and national leaders must step in and provide the guidance Ķvlog desperately need.

Here are a few ways leaders in state departments of education and the U.S. Department of Education could help, particularly with respect to math:

  • Good tools exist to identify what kids know and which critical gaps in their knowledge must be shored up. State leaders should help districts spend their COVID-recovery dollars on assessments that are embedded in curriculum and provide accurate, actionable information to teachers about areas of student need. Schools should be advised to make data-informed decisions and meet kids where they are academically, even if that isn’t grade-level standards. Forcing kids to tackle advanced skills before they have mastered the building blocks will result in most kids falling further behind.

  • After-school programs can be used to ensure that students have the time needed to acquire the skills necessary to learn advanced math. Given that few colleges are expanding remedial courses, it is essential that high schools enact measures to ensure kids are prepared for college. Greater communication and coordination between K-12 and higher education systems will also be needed.

  • Individualized tutoring could be a great solution, but there aren’t enough highly skilled tutors available. High-quality software programs such as Knowledgehook and online tutoring programs such as Zearn and Khan Academy can be used to help students and teachers; state departments should advise districts on the best programs and sources of support for these purposes.

  • Leaders should champion schools that provide curriculum-focused professional learning and offer time for teacher collaboration and for targeted intervention and support to address math deficiencies.

These math wars follow similar fights over how to teach reading. In those wars, specialists dug in, supporting either a phonics or whole-language approach. Despite the prolonged disputes, policymakers made progress by choosing a middle path. A similar outcome here would make the most sense for most students.

We cannot afford the math wars, the reading wars, or any of the other tiresome debates that produce paralysis and stymie meaningful action.

Leaders must find ways to make math relevant and interesting and they must ensure that their students are being prepared for advanced courses like algebra, geometry and calculus.

The truth is, we cannot afford the math wars, the reading wars, or any of the other tiresome debates that produce paralysis and stymie meaningful action. Education should be a nonpartisan issue, but increasingly, it’s not. Instead of fighting over how to teach math, we should be focused on how to support teachers and students in gaining math proficiency.

Again, access to learning math is a critical equity issue for our nation’s future. Leadership at the state and national levels is needed now to stop the fighting and begin moving our schools in a more constructive direction.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the September 21, 2022 edition of Education Week as How We Can Finally End the ‘Math Wars’

Events

College & Workforce Readiness Webinar How High Schools Can Prepare Students for College and Career
Explore how schools are reimagining high school with hands-on learning that prepares students for both college and career success.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School Climate & Safety Webinar
GoGuardian and Google: Proactive AI Safety in Schools
Learn how to safely adopt innovative AI tools while maintaining support for student well-being. 
Content provided by 
Reading & Literacy K-12 Essentials Forum Supporting Struggling Readers in Middle and High School
Join this free virtual event to learn more about policy, data, research, and experiences around supporting older students who struggle to read.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Mathematics High-Achieving Black and Latino Students Are Often Shut Out of Algebra 1
Middle schoolers' access to the course is stratified along racial, socioeconomic, and regional lines, new research finds.
3 min read
Logan Jeffiers teaches an eighth grade pre-algebra class on April 28, 2023, at Medlin Middle School in Trophy Club, Texas.
Logan Jeffiers teaches an eighth grade prealgebra class on April 28, 2023, at Medlin Middle School in Trophy Club, Texas. New data confirm that even when they have similar academic marks as their white peers, Black and Latino students tend to have less access to the gatekeeping course of Algebra 1.
Amanda McCoy/Fort Worth Star-Telegram via TNS
Mathematics Opinion Want Students to Gain Math Confidence? Celebrate Their Mistakes
A veteran educator shares six ways student errors can reshape how math is taught and experienced.
Wendy W. Amato
5 min read
A group of students leaps from x's and math symbols. Learning from their math mistakes.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week + Getty Images
Mathematics Spotlight Spotlight on Building Foundational Math Skills and Beyond
This Spotlight will provide insights on helping students build foundational math skills.
Mathematics Spotlight Spotlight on Teaching Tools to Make the Math Journey Easier
Students need to see math as useful and doable. This Spotlight focuses on giving teachers tools to help in that journey.